Idea Statica
  • Steel
  • Concrete
  • BIM & Workflows
  • Support & Learning
  • Pricing
  • Company
  • Steel overview
  • Connection design
  • Member design
  • Parametric design
  • Steel case studies
  • Concrete overview
  • Walls and D-regions
  • Anchoring design
  • Concrete case studies
  • BIM Overview
  • Supported integrations
  • Checkbot
  • Viewer
  • APIs
  • Support Center
  • E-learning & certification
  • Blog
  • Downloads & Licensing
  • Plans
  • Free community tool
  • Enterprise customers
  • Students & educators
  • How much will you save?
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Research & development
  • Authorized resellers
  • Meet our customers
  • Career
  • Steel
    Steel overviewConnection designMember designParametric designSteel case studies
  • Concrete
    Concrete overviewWalls and D-regionsAnchoring designConcrete case studies
  • BIM & Workflows
    BIM OverviewSupported integrationsCheckbotViewerAPIs
  • Support & Learning
    Support CenterE-learning & certificationBlogDownloads & Licensing
  • Pricing
    PlansFree community toolEnterprise customersStudents & educatorsHow much will you save?
  • Company
    About usContactResearch & developmentAuthorized resellersMeet our customersCareer
14-Day Trial
14-Day Trial

Subscribe to our newsletter

Company

  • About us
  • Partners
  • Careers
  • Patent

Resources

  • Customer projects
  • Case studies
  • Connection Library
  • Verification books

Legal

  • EULA
  • Global privacy policy
  • California Privacy
  • TOS Viewer
  • Licensing

Help

  • Contact
  • Quote request
  • Resellers
  • Downloads
FacebookInstagramLinkedInYouTube

ยฉ IDEA StatiCa 2009-2026

Trusted and used worldwide by engineers, fabricators & consultants.

Support CenterKnowledge Base ArticlesFatigue analysis according to EN 1993-1-9
Advanced analysis types for your steel structures
Fatigue analysis: nominal stress
Fatigue analysis - how the results are displayed
Fatigue analysis according to EN 1993-1-9
Fatigue analysis type in structural design
Fatigue analysis according to EN 1993-1-9
SteelConnection designKnowledge baseConnectionEN (Eurocode)

Fatigue analysis according to EN 1993-1-9

This article is also available in
ENCZDEESFRITPTNLHUROKRPLTHTRVIZH

IDEA Connection provides nominal stresses for the sections in plates, sections near welds and bolts. The nominal stresses may be used in further analysis to determine the accumulated damage.

This article shows how to use nominal stresses provided by IDEA Connection to perform full fatigue analysis according to EN 1993-1-9.

IDEA Connection provides nominal stresses in:

  • user-defined sections
  • sections near welds
  • bolts and anchors

The provided stresses are the stress range between the load effect and the reference load effect. The stress range is not modified in any way, e.g. in terms of the below-shown figure, which allows decreasing the stress range if the stress changes from tension to compression.

These stresses include some stress concentration factors, e.g. concentration of stresses near bolt holes.

Other factors, e.g. partial factor for equivalent constant amplitude stress ranges ฮณFf\gamma_{Ff}ฮณFfโ€‹ according to EN 1991 or k1 factors for hollow section joints due to neglected bending moments in truss model still have to be included.

IDEA Connection provides ฯƒmax\sigma_{max}ฯƒmaxโ€‹ and ฯ„max\tau_{max}ฯ„maxโ€‹ to be used to obtain ฮ”ฯƒ\Delta \sigmaฮ”ฯƒ and ฮ”ฯ„\Delta \tauฮ”ฯ„.ย 

ฮ”ฯƒ=ฮณFfโ‹…kxโ‹…ฯƒmax\Delta \sigma = \gamma_{Ff} \cdot k_x \cdot \sigma_{max}ฮ”ฯƒ=ฮณFfโ€‹โ‹…kxโ€‹โ‹…ฯƒmaxโ€‹

ฮ”ฯ„=ฮณFfโ‹…kxโ‹…ฯƒmax\Delta \tau = \gamma_{Ff} \cdot k_x \cdot \sigma_{max}ฮ”ฯ„=ฮณFfโ€‹โ‹…kxโ€‹โ‹…ฯƒmaxโ€‹

where:

  • ฮณFf\gamma_{Ff}ฮณFfโ€‹ โ€“ partial factor for equivalent constant amplitude stress ranges
  • kxk_xkxโ€‹ โ€“ any factors not included in the analysis, e.g. k1k_1k1โ€‹ from Table 4.1 or 4.2
  • ฯƒmax\sigma_{max}ฯƒmaxโ€‹ โ€“ IDEA Connection output of normal stress
  • ฯ„max\tau_{max}ฯ„maxโ€‹ โ€“ IDEA Connection output of shear stress

According to Chapter 8, Equation (8.1), following stress limitations must be satisfied:

ฮ”ฯƒโ‰ค1.5fy\Delta \sigma \le 1.5 f_yฮ”ฯƒโ‰ค1.5fyโ€‹

ฮ”ฯ„โ‰ค1.5fy/3\Delta \tau \le 1.5 f_y / \sqrt{3}ฮ”ฯ„โ‰ค1.5fyโ€‹/3โ€‹

where fyf_yfyโ€‹ is steel yield strength.

The detail has to be categorized according to Tables 8.1โ€“8.10 and all relevant factors must be taken into account, e.g. the factor for size effects. The detail category (reduced by e.g. size effect factor) provides the fatigue strength at 2 million cycles, ฮ”ฯƒc\Delta \sigma_cฮ”ฯƒcโ€‹ and ฮ”ฯ„c\Delta \tau_cฮ”ฯ„cโ€‹. The values of ฮ”ฯƒc\Delta \sigma_cฮ”ฯƒcโ€‹ and ฮ”ฯ„c\Delta \tau_cฮ”ฯ„cโ€‹ should be reduced by partial factor for fatigue strength, ฮณMf\gamma_{Mf}ฮณMfโ€‹.

Table 3.1 from EN 1993-1-9 with values of ฮณMf\gamma_{Mf}ฮณMfโ€‹:

Assessment methodConsequence of failureย 
ย Low consequenceย High consequence
Damage tolerant11.15
Safe lifeย 1.151.35

The limits of S-N (stress-life) curve are determined according to Chapter 7.1:

ฮ”ฯƒD=(25)1/3ฮ”ฯƒc\Delta \sigma_D = \left ( \frac{2}{5} \right )^{1/3} \Delta \sigma_cฮ”ฯƒDโ€‹=(52โ€‹)1/3ฮ”ฯƒcโ€‹

ฮ”ฯƒL=(5100)1/5ฮ”ฯƒD\Delta \sigma_L = \left ( \frac{5}{100} \right )^{1/5} \Delta \sigma_Dฮ”ฯƒLโ€‹=(1005โ€‹)1/5ฮ”ฯƒDโ€‹

ฮ”ฯ„L=(2100)1/5ฮ”ฯ„c\Delta \tau_L = \left ( \frac{2}{100} \right )^{1/5} \Delta \tau_cฮ”ฯ„Lโ€‹=(1002โ€‹)1/5ฮ”ฯ„cโ€‹

According to Chapter A.5, cycles to failure should be determined. Number of cycles, nEin_{Ei}nEiโ€‹, associated with stress range ฮณFfฮ”ฯƒi\gamma_{Ff} \Delta \sigma_iฮณFfโ€‹ฮ”ฯƒiโ€‹, is an input from the user. NRiN_{Ri}NRiโ€‹ is calculated according to Chapter 7.ย 

Normal stresses for ฮ”ฯƒโ‰ฅฮ”ฯƒD\Delta \sigma \ge \Delta \sigma_Dฮ”ฯƒโ‰ฅฮ”ฯƒDโ€‹:

NR=ฮ”ฯƒcmโ‹…2โ‹…106ฮ”ฯƒmN_R = \frac{\Delta \sigma_c^m \cdot 2\cdot 10^6}{\Delta \sigma^m}NRโ€‹=ฮ”ฯƒmฮ”ฯƒcmโ€‹โ‹…2โ‹…106โ€‹

where:

  • m = 3 โ€“ slope of fatigue strength curveย 

Normal stresses for ฮ”ฯƒโ‰ฅฮ”ฯƒL\Delta \sigma \ge \Delta \sigma_Lฮ”ฯƒโ‰ฅฮ”ฯƒLโ€‹:

NR=ฮ”ฯƒDmโ‹…5โ‹…106ฮ”ฯƒmN_R = \frac{\Delta \sigma_D^m \cdot 5\cdot 10^6}{\Delta \sigma^m}NRโ€‹=ฮ”ฯƒmฮ”ฯƒDmโ€‹โ‹…5โ‹…106โ€‹

where:

  • m = 5 โ€“ slope of fatigue strength curveย 

The normal stresses below cut-off limit ฮ”ฯƒL\Delta \sigma_Lฮ”ฯƒLโ€‹ do not participate to fatigue damage.

Shear stresses for ฮ”ฯ„Eโ‰คฮ”ฯ„L\Delta \tau_E \le \Delta \tau_Lฮ”ฯ„Eโ€‹โ‰คฮ”ฯ„Lโ€‹:

NR=ฮ”ฯ„cmโ‹…2โ‹…106ฮ”ฯ„mN_R = \frac{\Delta \tau_c^m \cdot 2\cdot 10^6}{\Delta \tau^m}NRโ€‹=ฮ”ฯ„mฮ”ฯ„cmโ€‹โ‹…2โ‹…106โ€‹

where:

  • m = 5 โ€“ slope of fatigue strength curveย 

The shear stresses below the cut-off limit ฮ”ฯ„L\Delta \tau_Lฮ”ฯ„Lโ€‹ do not participate in fatigue damage.

The damage is calculated according to Palmgren-Miner rule (Figure A.1) in Equations (A.1) and (A.2) separately for normal and shear stress:

Dd=ฮฃinnEiNRiโ‰ค1.0D_d = \Sigma_i^n \frac{n_{Ei}}{N_{Ri}} \le 1.0Ddโ€‹=ฮฃinโ€‹NRiโ€‹nEiโ€‹โ€‹โ‰ค1.0

The normal stress and shear stress should be combined by Equation (8.3), unless otherwise stated in Tables 8.8 and 8.9.

Ddฯƒ3+Ddฯ„5ย โ‰ค1.0D_{d \sigma}^3 + D_{d \tau}^5ย \le 1.0Ddฯƒ3โ€‹+Ddฯ„5โ€‹ย โ‰ค1.0

Example

Inputs for calculation: The user sets a reference load effect and three fatigue load effects. The outputs from IDEA Connection are the maximum normal stress and the corresponding shear stress. The steel grade is S355.

Load effectNumber of cyclesMaximum normal stressCorresponding shear stress

nEฮ”ฯƒmax [MPa]ฮ”ฯ„ [MPa]
LE21 500 0006060
LE33 000 0005040
LE410 000 0002010

Partial safety factors are determined from EN 1991 and EN 1993-1-9:

ฮณFf=1.0\gamma_{Ff} = 1.0ฮณFfโ€‹=1.0

ฮณMf=1.15\gamma_{Mf} = 1.15ฮณMfโ€‹=1.15

Stress limitations are checked:

ฮ”ฯƒโ‰ค1.5fy\Delta \sigma \le 1.5 f_yฮ”ฯƒโ‰ค1.5fyโ€‹

60ย โ€‰MPaโ‰ค1.5โ‹…355=532โ€‰MPa60ย \, \textrm{MPa} \le 1.5 \cdot 355 = 532 \, \textrm{MPa}60ย MPaโ‰ค1.5โ‹…355=532MPa

ฮ”ฯ„โ‰ค1.5fy/3\Delta \tau \le 1.5 f_y / \sqrt{3}ฮ”ฯ„โ‰ค1.5fyโ€‹/3โ€‹

60ย โ€‰MPaโ‰ค1.5โ‹…355/3=307โ€‰MPa60 ย \, \textrm{MPa} \le 1.5 \cdot 355 / \sqrt{3} = 307 \, \textrm{MPa}60ย MPaโ‰ค1.5โ‹…355/3โ€‹=307MPa

From Tables 8.1โ€“8.10, values of ฮ”ฯƒc=90โ€‰MPa\Delta \sigma_c = 90\,\textrm{MPa}ฮ”ฯƒcโ€‹=90MPa and ฮ”ฯ„c=70โ€‰MPa\Delta \tau_c = 70\,\textrm{MPa}ฮ”ฯ„cโ€‹=70MPa are determined. These values are reduced by reduced by partial factor for fatigue strength, ฮณMf=1.15\gamma_{Mf} = 1.15ฮณMfโ€‹=1.15 to ฮ”ฯƒc=78.3โ€‰MPa\Delta \sigma_c = 78.3\,\textrm{MPa}ฮ”ฯƒcโ€‹=78.3MPaย and ฮ”ฯ„c=60.9โ€‰MPa\Delta \tau_c = 60.9\,\textrm{MPa}ฮ”ฯ„cโ€‹=60.9MPa.

The limits of S-N curve are determined:

ฮ”ฯƒD=(25)1/3ฮ”ฯƒc=(25)1/378.3=57.7โ€‰MPa\Delta \sigma_D = \left ( \frac{2}{5} \right )^{1/3} \Delta \sigma_c = \left ( \frac{2}{5} \right )^{1/3} 78.3 = 57.7\,\textrm{MPa}ฮ”ฯƒDโ€‹=(52โ€‹)1/3ฮ”ฯƒcโ€‹=(52โ€‹)1/378.3=57.7MPa

ฮ”ฯƒL=(5100)1/5ฮ”ฯƒD=(5100)1/557.7=31.7โ€‰MPa\Delta \sigma_L = \left ( \frac{5}{100} \right )^{1/5} \Delta \sigma_D = \left ( \frac{5}{100} \right )^{1/5} 57.7 = 31.7 \,\textrm{MPa}ฮ”ฯƒLโ€‹=(1005โ€‹)1/5ฮ”ฯƒDโ€‹=(1005โ€‹)1/557.7=31.7MPa

ฮ”ฯ„L=(2100)1/5ฮ”ฯ„c=(2100)1/560.9=27.8โ€‰MPa\Delta \tau_L = \left ( \frac{2}{100} \right )^{1/5} \Delta \tau_c = \left ( \frac{2}{100} \right )^{1/5} 60.9 = 27.8\,\textrm{MPa}ฮ”ฯ„Lโ€‹=(1002โ€‹)1/5ฮ”ฯ„cโ€‹=(1002โ€‹)1/560.9=27.8MPa

ย ฮ”ฯƒ\Delta \sigmaฮ”ฯƒ is determined by multiplying ย ฮ”ฯƒmax\Delta \sigma_{max}ฮ”ฯƒmaxโ€‹ by partial factor for equivalent constant amplitude stress ranges ฮณFf=1.0\gamma_{Ff} = 1.0ฮณFfโ€‹=1.0. In this example, no other factor kx is necessary.

Number of cycles to failure, NRN_RNRโ€‹ is calculated for each load case and normal and shear stress according to the above-mentioned formulas, e.g. for normal stress in LE2:

NR=ฮ”ฯƒcmโ‹…2โ‹…106ฮ”ฯƒm=78.33โ‹…2โ‹…106603=4โ€‰438โ€‰234โ€‰cyclesN_R = \frac{\Delta \sigma_c^m \cdot 2\cdot 10^6}{\Delta \sigma^m} = \frac{78.3^3 \cdot 2\cdot 10^6}{60^3} = 4 \,438\, 234 \, \textrm{cycles}NRโ€‹=ฮ”ฯƒmฮ”ฯƒcmโ€‹โ‹…2โ‹…106โ€‹=60378.33โ‹…2โ‹…106โ€‹=4438234cycles

Load effectNumber of cyclesMaximum normal stressCorresponding shear stress
Number of cycles to failure
Number of cycles to failure

nEฮ”ฯƒmax [MPa]ฮ”ฯ„ [MPa]ฮ”ฯƒ [MPa]NRฮ”ฯ„ [MPa]NR
LE21 500 0006060604 438 235602 149 190
LE33 000 00050405010 200 2304016 320 409
LE410 000 000201020infinity10infinity

Using Palmgren-Miner rule, the accumulated damage is calculated for all load effects.

For normal stresses:

Ddฯƒ=ฮฃinnEiNRi=1โ€‰500โ€‰0004โ€‰438โ€‰235+3โ€‰000โ€‰00010โ€‰200โ€‰230=0.632โ‰ค1.0D_{d \sigma} = \Sigma_i^n \frac{n_{Ei}}{N_{Ri}} = \frac{1\, 500\, 000}{4\, 438\, 235} + \frac{3\,000\,000}{10\,200\,230} = 0.632 \le 1.0Ddฯƒโ€‹=ฮฃinโ€‹NRiโ€‹nEiโ€‹โ€‹=44382351500000โ€‹+102002303000000โ€‹=0.632โ‰ค1.0

For shearย stresses:

Ddฯ„=ฮฃinnEiNRi=1โ€‰500โ€‰0002โ€‰149โ€‰190+3โ€‰000โ€‰00016โ€‰320โ€‰409=0.882โ‰ค1.0D_{d \tau} = \Sigma_i^n \frac{n_{Ei}}{N_{Ri}} = \frac{1\, 500\, 000}{2\, 149\, 190} + \frac{3\,000\,000}{16\,320\,409} = 0.882 \le 1.0Ddฯ„โ€‹=ฮฃinโ€‹NRiโ€‹nEiโ€‹โ€‹=21491901500000โ€‹+163204093000000โ€‹=0.882โ‰ค1.0

Finally, the interaction between normal and shear stress is checked:

Ddฯƒ3+Ddฯ„5ย โ‰ค1.0D_{d \sigma} ^3 + D_{d \tau} ^5ย \le 1.0Ddฯƒ3โ€‹+Ddฯ„5โ€‹ย โ‰ค1.0

0.6323+0.8825ย =0.786โ‰ค1.00.632 ^3 + 0.882 ^5ย  = 0.786 \le 1.00.6323+0.8825ย =0.786โ‰ค1.0

The fatigue resistance of the investigated detail is sufficient.

Verifications

Before releasing the Fatigue analysis tool, several experimental verifications have been performed:

Fatigue life by nominal stress method

Fatigue analysis โ€“ Butt welds of I section

Fatigue of steel due to cyclic loading
  • Steel
  • Connection
  • Load effects
  • CBFEM
  • Stress/strain
  • +5
  • Steel
  • Connection
  • Load effects
  • CBFEM
  • Stress/strain

Blog post

Fatigue of steel due to cyclic loading

Read more
Fatigue analysis in IDEA StatiCa
  • Steel
  • Connection
  • EN (Eurocode)
  • Fatigue
  • AISC (USA)
  • +5
  • Steel
  • Connection
  • EN (Eurocode)
  • Fatigue
  • AISC (USA)

Knowledge base

Fatigue analysis - how the results are displayed

Read more
Fatigue analysis: nominal stress
  • Steel
  • Connection
  • AISC (USA)
  • Stress/strain
  • Fatigue
  • EN (Eurocode)
  • +6
  • Steel
  • Connection
  • AISC (USA)
  • Stress/strain
  • Fatigue
  • EN (Eurocode)

Knowledge base

Fatigue analysis: nominal stress

Read more
Fatigue analysis type serves to determine normal and shear stress range between two load cases. IDEA StatiCa - structural design software for modeling and code-checking steel connections.
  • Steel
  • AISC (USA)
  • Bolts
  • Plates
  • Welds
  • EN (Eurocode)
  • +6
  • Steel
  • AISC (USA)
  • Bolts
  • Plates
  • Welds
  • EN (Eurocode)

Knowledge base

Fatigue analysis type in structural design

Read more