Idea Statica
  • Steel
  • Concrete
  • BIM & Workflows
  • Support & Learning
  • Pricing
  • Company
  • Steel overview
  • Connection design
  • Member design
  • Parametric design
  • Steel case studies
  • Concrete overview
  • Walls and D-regions
  • Anchoring design
  • Concrete case studies
  • BIM Overview
  • Supported integrations
  • Checkbot
  • Viewer
  • APIs
  • Support Center
  • E-learning & certification
  • Blog
  • Downloads & Licensing
  • Plans
  • Free community tool
  • Enterprise customers
  • Students & educators
  • How much will you save?
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Research & development
  • Authorized resellers
  • Meet our customers
  • Career
  • Steel
    Steel overviewConnection designMember designParametric designSteel case studies
  • Concrete
    Concrete overviewWalls and D-regionsAnchoring designConcrete case studies
  • BIM & Workflows
    BIM OverviewSupported integrationsCheckbotViewerAPIs
  • Support & Learning
    Support CenterE-learning & certificationBlogDownloads & Licensing
  • Pricing
    PlansFree community toolEnterprise customersStudents & educatorsHow much will you save?
  • Company
    About usContactResearch & developmentAuthorized resellersMeet our customersCareer
14-Day Trial
14-Day Trial

Subscribe to our newsletter

Company

  • About us
  • Partners
  • Careers
  • Patent

Resources

  • Customer projects
  • Case studies
  • Connection Library
  • Verification books

Legal

  • EULA
  • Global privacy policy
  • California Privacy
  • TOS Viewer
  • Licensing

Help

  • Contact
  • Quote request
  • Resellers
  • Downloads
FacebookInstagramLinkedInYouTube

© IDEA StatiCa 2009-2026

Trusted and used worldwide by engineers, fabricators & consultants.

Support CenterVerification examplesEnd plate connection with four bolts in row
SteelConnection designVerificationsEN (Eurocode)CBFEM

End plate connection with four bolts in row

This article is also available in
ENCZDEESFRITPTNLHUROKRPLTHTRVIZH

This is a selected chapter from book Component-based finite element design of steel connections by prof. Wald et al. The chapter is focused on verification of end plate connection with four bolts in row

Description

This study is focused on the verification of the component-based finite element method (CBFEM) for the resistance of the end plate connection with four bolts in a row to an analytical model (AM), and a research-oriented finite element model (ROFEM) validated on experiments.

Analytical model

The bolt resistance in shear and tension and the plate resistance in bearing and punching shear are designed according to Tab. 3.4, Chapter 3.6.1 in EN 1993-1-8:2006. The equivalent T-stub in tension, according to Chapter 6.2.4, was modified by Jaspart et al. (2010) , see Fig. 5.7.1 and Tab. 5.7.1.

Fig. 5.7.1 Failure modes of T-stub with four bolts in a row: mode 1 (left), mode 2 (middle), mode 3 (right)\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 5.7.1 Failure modes of T-stub with four bolts in a row: mode 1 (left), mode 2 (middle), mode 3 (right)}}}Fig. 5.7.1 Failure modes of T-stub with four bolts in a row: mode 1 (left), mode 2 (middle), mode 3 (right)

Tab. 5.7.1 Failure modes of T-stub with four bolts in a row (Jaspart et al. 2010)

In Tab 5.7.1 is 𝐹t,Rd the bolt tensile resistance, 𝑒w=𝑑w/4, 𝑑w is the diameter of the washer, or the width across points of the bolt head or nut, as relevant, 𝑚, 𝑛=𝑒1+𝑒2;⁡𝑛≤1.25𝑚, 𝑛1=𝑒1, 𝑛2=𝑒2;⁡𝑛2≤1,25𝑚+𝑛1 see Fig. 5.8.2, 𝑀pl,1,Rd=0.25𝑙eff,1𝑡f2𝑓y/𝛾M0, 𝑀pl,2,Rd=0.25𝑙eff,2𝑡f2𝑓y/𝛾M0, 𝑙eff is effective length, 𝑡f is the flange thickness, and 𝑓y is the yield strength, see Fig. 5.7.2.

Fig. 5.7.2 T-stub geometry with four bolts in a row\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 5.7.2 T-stub geometry with four bolts in a row}}}Fig. 5.7.2 T-stub geometry with four bolts in a row

Validation and verification of resistance

Design resistances calculated by CBFEM were compared with the results of the analytical model (Zakouřil, 2019) and experiments with research-oriented finite element model (Samaan et al. 2017), see Fig. 5.7.3. The results are summarized in Fig. 5.7.4. Bolt grade 8.8 and steel grade S450 were used. The yield and tensile strengths correspond closely to the experimental values, e.g. bolt yield strength is 600 MPa, bolt tensile strength is 800 MPa.

Extended unstiffened end plate labeled ENS\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Extended unstiffened end plate labeled ENS}}}Extended unstiffened end plate labeled ENS

Flushed end plate labeled F\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Flushed end plate labeled F}}}Flushed end plate labeled F

Extended stiffened end plate labeled EX\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Extended stiffened end plate labeled EX}}}Extended stiffened end plate labeled EX

Fig. 5.7.3 Tested specimens\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 5.7.3 Tested specimens}}}Fig. 5.7.3 Tested specimens

The bending moment resistance determined by CBFEM is usually between resistances determined by the component method and experimentally. Table 5.7.2 shows the comparison between the CM, CBFEM, ROFEM, and experimental resistances for the specimens with end plate thicknesses of 20 mm and 32 mm. Both the component method and CBFEM underestimate the resistance of the specimen with a flushed end plate. 

Tab. 5.7.2 Comparison between the CM , ROFEM, CBFEM, and Experiment

Table 5.7.3 and Fig. 5.7.4 show verification of CBFEM to CM for models ENS with different end plate thickness, bolt diameter, and beam height

Tab. 5.7.3 Verification CBFEM to CM ENS

Fig. 5.7.4 Verification of CBFEM to CM\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 5.7.4 Verification of CBFEM to CM}}}Fig. 5.7.4 Verification of CBFEM to CM

The results of sensitivity studies are summarized in plots in Fig. 5.7.5, Fig. 5.7.6, Fig. 5.7.7 

Fig. 5.7.5 Sensitivity study for plate thickness\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 5.7.5 Sensitivity study for plate thickness}}}Fig. 5.7.5 Sensitivity study for plate thickness

Fig. 5.7.6 Sensitivity study for bolt diameter\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 5.7.6 Sensitivity study for bolt diameter}}}Fig. 5.7.6 Sensitivity study for bolt diameter

Fig. 5.7.7 Sensitivity study for beam height\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 5.7.7 Sensitivity study for beam height}}}Fig. 5.7.7 Sensitivity study for beam height

Table 5.7.4 and Fig. 5.7.8 show verification of CBFEM to CM for models F with different end plate thickness and bolt diameter 

Tab. 5.7.4 Verification CBFEM to CM F

Fig. 5.7.8 Verification of CBFEM to CM\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 5.7.8 Verification of CBFEM to CM}}}Fig. 5.7.8 Verification of CBFEM to CM

The results of sensitivity studies are summarized in plots in Fig. 5.7.9 and 5.7.10

Fig. 5.7.9 Sensitivity study for plate thickness\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 5.7.9 Sensitivity study for plate thickness}}}Fig. 5.7.9 Sensitivity study for plate thickness

Fig. 5.7.10 Sensitivity study for bolt diameter\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 5.7.10 Sensitivity study for bolt diameter}}}Fig. 5.7.10 Sensitivity study for bolt diameter

Table 5.7.5 and Fig. 5.7.11 show verification of CBFEM to CM for models F with different end plate thickness and bolt diameter 

Tab. 5.7.5 Verification CBFEM to CM EX

Fig. 5.7.11 Verification of CBFEM to CM\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 5.7.11 Verification of CBFEM to CM}}}Fig. 5.7.11 Verification of CBFEM to CM

The results of sensitivity studies are summarized in plots in Fig. 5.7.12 and 5.7.13. 

Fig. 5.7.12 Sensitivity study for plate thickness\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 5.7.12 Sensitivity study for plate thickness}}}Fig. 5.7.12 Sensitivity study for plate thickness

Fig. 5.7.13 Sensitivity study for bolt diameter\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 5.7.13 Sensitivity study for bolt diameter}}}Fig. 5.7.13 Sensitivity study for bolt diameter

Benchmark example

Inputs

  • Steel S450

Column

  • Rolled I
  • h = 390mm
  • b = 350mm
  • tf = 20mm
  • tw = 12mm
  • r = 27mm

Column stiffeners

  • ts = 16mm

Beam

  • Rolled I
  • hb = 340mm
  • bb = 350mm
  • tf = 20mm
  • tw = 12mm
  • r = 27mm

End plate

  • tp = 20mm
  • bp = 350mm
  • hp= 540mm

Bolts

  • 4 rows x 4 x M16 8.8
  • Distances e1 = 50 mm, p1 = 120 mm, p2 = 100mm, e2= 50mm, w1 = 75mm, w2 = 100mm

Welds

  • aw = 7mm

Outputs

  • Design resistance FRd = 247 kN
  • Critical components are bolts with forces increased by the prying of the end plate

Fig. 5.7.14 Benchmark example\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 5.7.14 Benchmark example}}}Fig. 5.7.14 Benchmark example

Open in ViewerDownload